February 10, 2007

Stuart & W. Primeau for A. Ference & Kobasew

I'm sure there'll be a lot of talk about this trade. Stuart was a big disappointment in the Thornton trade that blew up in Boston's face and they're still suffering because of it. In general I believe it's a bad idea to pick up the top defenseman on a bad team (they account for a big percentage of the badness of the team).

Stuart:
Calgary needed to get their power play going so they picked up a guy who is currently running at 1.8 GF/hr on the power play and if you include goals against essentially a big 0. His defensive numbers would make anyone cringe: -4.5GA/hr and +3GF/hr, for a total of -1.5 +/- /HR. In terms of the plus scoring rate he's one of the best on the team, but a -4.5GA/hr is something to worry about (ranked 229/231).

Primeau:
Popular probably because of his experience, because he doesn't help teams much. He's arguably the worst forward on Boston at even strength, doesn't help much on the PK and doesn't add much to the power play. Scores about 0.25 points per game, which is below what I consider marginal (0.25). However, I believe people consider him a leader. He seems able to stay in the NHL. According to Sportsnet he is a good penalty killer (hasn't panned out this year).

Ference:
He's D man #4 based on ice time, is the best defense man (statistically) on a reasonable poor PK. Signed for 4 years below market value.

Kobasew:
Thee guys are a dime a dozen, sure he's young, but I don't think he's going to be a top line center. He's probably more valuable than Primeau though.

I see this trade as Calgary throwing away some defense for some short term offense they believe they'll need in the playoffs. They may have thrown away too much defense (as a Canuck fan I can only hope). I generally think it's bad to take a #1 defenseman from a bad team as they are likely contributing to the problems. The numbers in this trade don't make sense on the numbers side. Scouting people might be able to make sense of it. It seems strange to me that a team would want the worst statistical players from a bad team for a couple average players on a good team, that appears to be what has happened here. Looks like a bad trade on the surface, but only time will tell.

February 7, 2007

Huselius Diving

There’s another triple threat player in the diving mix, Huselius now has three [1, 2, 3] diving calls against him, however all this appear mute as Hockey Operations disagrees with most of the on ice officials diving calls. When a dive (or unsportsmanlike conduct) occurs Hockey Operations takes over to determine the appropriate action:

In addition to the minor penalty for unsportsmanlike conduct/diving that may be assessed by the Referee during a game, Hockey Operations will review game videos and assess fines to players who dive or embellish a fall or a reaction, or who feigns injury in an attempt to draw penalties. (NHL.com)


Avery is the only individual who has received a public $1000 fine (and did not receive the $2000 fine on his third dive), the rest of the players may have been fined privately, but that would be unfair and strange for the NHL. Interestingly, Huselius, Chara, Plekanec, Selanne, Selanne, Hinote, Forsberg and Armstrong all should have received fines of $1000 if the NHL agreed with the on ice officials. If you use this information you can estimate the agreement level. For example I’m 95% confident that the NHL is disagreeing at or above 65% of the time and 66% confident that the number is as high as 80% based on these numbers. Considering there has 87 diving calls (62 of which included a hook, hold or a trip to the other team). If as I say: the NHL is only agreeing about one third of the time, that leaves us with about 29 legitimate diving calls this year (and that’s an upper bound).

The proverbial slap on the wrist will never rid the NHL of diving, but as I said before the NHL likes diving as it increases power plays and power plays increase goals and the current management believes that only goals make for good entertainment. It's no surprise they deal with diving the way they do: a lot of pretty ideas on paper with no action.

P.S.
I posted a diving update last month that showed diving calls had fallen from 0.12/game to 0.06/game, however the next 100 games it has gone back to the 0.12/game level as there were 12 diving calls for games 700-799. Either the drop over games 500-699 was due to random variations or the NHL reads this site...

Chaos Theory

When David Johnson's player rankings came out I initially posted that "goals occur randomly" and as a result, using information from a small sample hurts his analysis significantly. David Johnson replied simply that "Goals don’t occur randomly". While I can argue that they do occur randomly, I have more trouble proving that goals are not random, which got me thinking: are goals random? Statistically goals appear to be a random variable, however this does not make them random. In fact I would argue that with all possible information a goal is completely predictable, the problem is that this information is not available or not possible to get. For example the dents and shape of the ice could have an effect on the direction of a shot or the ability to pass. Consider the variables in the shooter: heart rate, blood pressure, emotional variables, physical muscle strength at any given time, oxygen concentration in the blood etc. The number of possible variables is essentially infinite. If you Knew all the variables you should be able to say if the situation will produce a goals, save, a blocked shot or a missed shot.

Why then do goals appear so random?
In simple terms, Chaos Theory can be summarized by the butterfly effect: "The phrase refers to the idea that a butterfly's wings might create tiny changes in the atmosphere that ultimately cause a tornado to appear (or, for that matter, prevent a tornado from appearing). The flapping wing represents a small change in the initial condition of the system, which causes a chain of events leading to large-scale phenomena. Had the butterfly not flapped its wings, the trajectory of the system might have been vastly different." (Wikipedia). The main point of chaos is there is a strong dependence on initial conditions as you can see in the graph to the right a difference 0.00127 resulted in the curves to eventually be on opposite sides of the graph. A chaotic system's dynamics are fully understood, so given any initial condition the result at any moment in time is known, however a small change has unpredictable effects. There are a number of real systems that are chaotic including the most classic of all examples: The Lorenzian Waterwheel. A number of other examples can be found here. A coin toss could be argued is a chaotic as could a roll of a dice, although most would agree that they are in fact random. I don't have an article: but a few years back I heard of a couple guys who could predict the numbers for the lottery as the lottery corporation used a random number generator and the individuals discovered all the initial conditions and knew the generating function and were therefor able to predict the winning numbers.

"So, is flipping a coin a random event? It really depends on the definition of the word 'random'. If we take it to mean that the outcome is theoretically unpredictable then no, the coin flip is not random. But in the real world it is practically impossible to predict the outcome of a good flip, so in that respect we can call it a random event." (Random Number Generator).

Alan Ryder concludes after going through great analysis that: "Goal scoring in a hockey game is basically a Poisson process." (Poisson Toolbox [PDF]). It is the result of hockey being chaotic with unknown variables that makes a completely determined system appear random. The more information we have on the dynamics of hockey and the more variables we know the less random the game will become. That being said, the chaotic properties would still exist and unless we had exact (infinite decimal places) values for all (infinite amount) of the information the game would still have significant random properties. And this in fact makes the game exciting. If we could predict with 100% certainty every event in hockey it wouldn't be too excite, how many people actually watch sports re-runs?

February 6, 2007

Determining an anomaly.

Sometimes you look at a leader and wonder: are they really that good. Lundqvist was the best goaltender last year based on shot quality neutral save percentage and this year he's ranked around 15th, not bad, but not the best. Backstrom is ranked first (as of the weekend, Feb 4. - allowed 4 goals on 35 shots on Feb. 6) with a .933 SQN%. For those who are not familiar a shot quality neutral save percentage is a save percentages based on expected goals rather than shots (shots determine how many expect goals, PP shots have a higher percentage of going in for example). Recently I've been sorting teams by save percentage in different situations and found that my opinion on who is the best goaltending team better correlated with PK save percentage as opposed to even strength percentage (goalie skill more important on the penalty kill - this makes sense). Technically speaking you want to be good at both: PK and EV, but sometimes skill or luck changes the results. Below is a graph of SQN% vs. PK%, the ratio should be 1 to 1, PK% = SQN%, but the regression tends to an average a bit so it's more like SQN% = 50 + 0.5*aPK%, this makes sense as players appear to be "regressing to the mean".

If a player is significantly different from the average (the regression line) it would suggest that the player is an anomaly or that it's either been lucky or unlucky (you can generally determine which by looking at their past)

What I find interesting is Backstrom is doing amazing, but his results don't mesh with that of Luongo, Kolzig and Huet who have similar PK%'s, but worse SQN%'s. Cloutier is better than his 0.869 rating would suggest as is Esche. Dunham has been bit lucky and Auld with an excellent 0.915 PK% has done poorly at even strength. You can make your own concussions based on these results, but this is a tool I use to try and figure out to some degree if a player is lucky or actually good. Mason seems to be actually good, of course there are many other indicators that could prove otherwise.

February 5, 2007

Hooking, Holding and Tripping

In the new NHL three penalties took a new level of importance: Hooking, Holding and Tripping. This post looks at the hooking, holding and tripping rates (combined) for individuals and teams. No one generally looks at these three penalties very often. Only one number is generally reported to the NHL: Penalty Minutes and Quantity of penalties, which includes many other penalties. I find this information interesting. I don't have too much to say about it, so most of this post is data. I should mention I scaled ice time differently for PP, SH andEV due to the fact the rates are different, these scale factors were poorly estimated though. As per usual all stats ("the rates") are penalties per hour, so Madden has 0.0687 hooks, holds and trips per hour. I included a NUM column so you can see how few of these calls each player actually gets.

Individual results
NFILastnamePENNUMTEAM
1JMADDEN0.06871N.J
2JLEHTINEN0.07431DAL
3ILAPERRIERE0.09201COL
4PMARTIN0.09602N.J
5SWALKER0.13472CAR
6PBOUCHARD0.13842MIN
7SSULLIVAN0.14382NSH
8IWHITE0.14752TOR
9JO'NEILL0.15952TOR
10SRUCCHIN0.16062ATL
11SSAMSONOV0.16212MTL
12AOVECHKIN0.16233WSH
13VKOZLOV0.16983ATL
14APICARD0.17582PHI
15DLANGKOW0.18293CGY
16BBURNS0.18352MIN
17BRICHARDS0.20134T.B
18BSMOLINSKI0.20953CHI
19JPANDOLFO0.21243N.J
20JLUPUL0.21423EDM
21JDUMONT0.21563NSH
22JTHORNTON0.22394S.J
23PKARIYA0.22524NSH
24WWOLSKI0.23033COL
25JLILES0.23053COL
26MRIBEIRO0.23793DAL
27TKABERLE0.23825TOR
28MGRIER0.23843S.J
29JJOKINEN0.24163DAL
30ASTEEN0.24283TOR
31RSUTER0.25514NSH
32CWHITE0.26114N.J
33RWHITNEY0.26575PIT
34DHEATLEY0.26685OTT
35ZMICHALEK0.26805PHX
36MFISHER0.26933OTT
37RUMBERGER0.28223PHI
38CPRONGER0.28635ANA
39JIGINLA0.28704CGY
40MST. LOUIS0.29066T.B
41MVLASIC0.29705S.J
42LSMID0.29764EDM
43SGAGNE0.29995PHI
44EPERRIN0.30014T.B
45BSUTHERBY0.30103WSH
46SDOAN0.30574PHX
47THUNTER0.30873NYI
48MBELL0.30883S.J
49RREGEHR0.31145CGY
50SVEILLEUX0.31343MIN
51DPENNER0.31894ANA
52BRAFALSKI0.31917N.J
53PRISSMILLER0.31933S.J
54JVANDERMEER0.32034CHI
55MPARRISH0.32314MIN
56SZUBOV0.32336DAL
57MHOSSA0.32526ATL
58BHEDICAN0.32594CAR
59BRADIVOJEVIC0.33104MIN
60LVISNOVSKY0.33147L.A
61PEAVES0.33334OTT
62BSTUART0.33675BOS
63BGUERIN0.33825STL
64MBERGERON0.35315EDM
65SKAPANEN0.36264PHI
66GLATENDRESSE0.36764MTL
67SWEBER0.36926NSH
68ROLESZ0.37104FLA
69BLUKOWICH0.37135N.J
70MMICHALEK0.37945S.J
71TZAJAC0.38065N.J
72TWHITE0.38235MIN
73TPREISSING0.38255OTT
74MSATAN0.38796NYI
75VPELTONEN0.39114FLA
76IKOVALCHUK0.39148ATL
77RSCUDERI0.39245PIT
78PDATSYUK0.39326DET
79MCARLE0.39706S.J
80LSTEMPNIAK0.39845STL
81ZPARISE0.39966N.J
82RBRIND'AMOUR0.40167CAR
83MSTURM0.40285BOS
84AMCDONALD0.40376ANA
85EBELANGER0.40385CAR
86ONOLAN0.40425PHX
87PSCHAEFER0.40445OTT
88JARNOTT0.40465NSH
89SPAHLSSON0.40465ANA
90BLEBDA0.40585DET
91KMCLAREN0.40795S.J
92JWILLIAMS0.40827CAR
93AMILLER0.41016L.A
94CDRURY0.41396BUF
95VPROSPAL0.41447T.B
96PRANGER0.41487T.B
97PMARLEAU0.41707S.J
98AFOOTE0.41747CBJ
99YPERREAULT0.41775PHX
100AFROLOV0.41927L.A
101KHUSELIUS0.42436CGY
102TAMONTE0.42525CGY
103ABABCHUK0.43186CAR
104RNASH0.43936CBJ
105GZANON0.43954NSH
106JLANGENBRUNNER0.43957N.J
107BSOPEL0.44005L.A
108RVRBATA0.44156CHI
109SHANNAN0.44198S.J
110SWEISS0.44285FLA
111PELIAS0.44347N.J
112NSCHULTZ0.44607MIN
113MCAMMALLERI0.44907L.A
114VKOZLOV0.45316NYI
115FBEAUCHEMIN0.45487ANA
116JBLAKE0.45857NYI
117AKOPITAR0.46048L.A
118SMONTADOR0.46294FLA
119LNAGY0.46407PHX
120PNUMMELIN0.46556MIN
121BCAMPBELL0.46579BUF
122BBOYES0.46636BOS
123JWISNIEWSKI0.46815CHI
124NALEXEEV0.46916T.B
125MROZSIVAL0.46928NYR
126NHAGMAN0.47055DAL
127NLIDSTROM0.470910DET
128TVANEK0.47167BUF
129PDEMITRA0.47177MIN
130VLECAVALIER0.47219T.B
131BBETTS0.47725NYR
132JSTUMPEL0.47827FLA
133SO'DONNELL0.47827ANA
134BCLYMER0.47896WSH
135SBRYLIN0.48157N.J
136DSYDOR0.48167DAL
137BGIONTA0.48168N.J
138MJOHNSON0.48816MTL
139NHAVELID0.48849ATL
140AMESZAROS0.49289OTT
141DHAMHUIS0.49558NSH
142DWIDEMAN0.50058STL
143DLEGWAND0.50587NSH
144MSTRAKA0.50749NYR
145NZHERDEV0.51376CBJ
146GROBERTS0.51636FLA
147AMIETTINEN0.51716DAL
148ACARTER0.52216CBJ
149FKUBA0.52509T.B
150JCHEECHOO0.52547S.J
151RHAINSEY0.52569CBJ
152WMITCHELL0.52866VAN
153JCORVO0.52898OTT
154DHATCHER0.52929PHI
155TSELANNE0.53018ANA
156JGORGES0.53146S.J
157MGELINAS0.53216FLA
158KBALLARD0.53257PHX
159TMOEN0.53526ANA
160WREDDEN0.53607OTT
161MNYLANDER0.53969NYR
162ABRUNETTE0.54258COL
163MNORSTROM0.54299L.A
164DBOYLE0.543513T.B
165CCHELIOS0.54386DET
166JSIM0.54576ATL
167CNEIL0.55007OTT
168MSCHNEIDER0.55338DET
169JMELICHAR0.55456PIT
170FSJOSTROM0.55766PHX
171SO'BRIEN0.55947ANA
172CKUNITZ0.55988ANA
173KTIMONEN0.561210NSH
174DFRITSCHE0.56216CBJ
175JODUYA0.56678N.J
176MSILLINGER0.56808NYI
177PBERGERON0.56859BOS
178TPLEKANEC0.56947MTL
179AHEMSKY0.57207EDM
180DMORRIS0.57719PHX
181MLAPOINTE0.58027CHI
182RTORRES0.58407EDM
183AFERENCE0.58598CGY
184JPOMINVILLE0.58628BUF
185BPOTHIER0.586410WSH
186ZCHARA0.590312BOS
187TDALEY0.59228DAL
188CPHILLIPS0.593010OTT
189DKALININ0.59419BUF
190SHARTNELL0.59678NSH
191BSEABROOK0.60159CHI
192DALFREDSSON0.603510OTT
193SSALO0.60438VAN
194BALLEN0.607710FLA
195DBROWN0.60789L.A
196BMCLEAN0.61006COL
197JSPEZZA0.61398OTT
198PKUBINA0.61477TOR
199PAXELSSON0.61507BOS
200AKOTALIK0.61628BUF
201MSKOULA0.621910MIN
202CRIVET0.623310MTL
203DPHANEUF0.623913CGY
204SSOURAY0.625911MTL
205OSAPRYKIN0.62697PHX
206NPRATT0.63077T.B
207SAVERY0.63159L.A
208GMURRAY0.632410BOS
209SHORCOFF0.632410EDM
210SSTAIOS0.64309EDM
211TARNASON0.64348COL
212SGOMEZ0.64399N.J
213PCAJANEK0.64418STL
214NHORTON0.650810FLA
215MDANDENAULT0.65636MTL
216MKOMISAREK0.660910MTL
217SEMINGER0.66209WSH
218PPRUCHA0.66227NYR
219KRACHUNEK0.66289NYR
220BCLARK0.665012COL
221MGREEN0.66519WSH
222JSMITH0.665310EDM
223DKEITH0.669212CHI
224AVOLCHENKOV0.672010OTT
225HZETTERBERG0.672911DET
226BORPIK0.67377PIT
227BJACKMAN0.67418STL
228KJOHNSSON0.678012MIN
229SCROSBY0.678211PIT
230VVISHNEVSKI0.678510ATL
231PSYKORA0.679110EDM
232MRECCHI0.680411PIT
233MCOOKE0.68268VAN
234BSHANAHAN0.689511NYR
235TNUMMINEN0.690011BUF
236PMARA0.694511BOS
237RHAMRLIK0.699412CGY
238RWHITNEY0.707912CAR
239NKAPANEN0.70847ATL
240KSKRASTINS0.709211COL
241ESTAAL0.714513CAR
242JFRANZEN0.71627DET
243AMARKOV0.717013MTL
244MSAVARD0.721012BOS
245MERAT0.731011NSH
246MCULLEN0.73119NYR
247KKLEE0.732311COL
248AJOHNSON0.73257CBJ
249RKESLER0.73258VAN
250CARMSTRONG0.73909PIT
251CKILGER0.74188TOR
252JMODRY0.744010DAL
253MNASLUND0.749712VAN
254FTYUTIN0.752812NYR
255DMARKOV0.75309DET
256ATANGUAY0.753111CGY
257HSEDIN0.753312VAN
258JHEWARD0.75618WSH
259AKOVALEV0.758512MTL
260SBARNES0.75979DAL
261JHECHT0.760410BUF
262AALBERTS0.763611BOS
263RFEDOTENKO0.768611T.B
264RDVORAK0.770910STL
265DSEDIN0.777512VAN
266AVERMETTE0.77969OTT
267GDE VRIES0.779714ATL
268CSARICH0.783211T.B
269AHILBERT0.78417NYI
270RSALEI0.787315FLA
271JWILLIAMS0.78739DET
272BROLSTON0.787614MIN
273AERIKSSON0.790412CBJ
274JBOUWMEESTER0.793116FLA
275NPAETSCH0.79337BUF
276OJOKINEN0.793414FLA
277BSALVADOR0.800411STL
278EMALKIN0.801112PIT
279THOLMSTROM0.801810DET
280BMCCABE0.802317TOR
281CEHRHOFF0.803313S.J
282ECOLE0.804313CAR
283JMAYERS0.80488STL
284PSTASTNY0.811611COL
285EJOVANOVSKI0.811714PHX
286RBLAKE0.815416L.A
287SNIEDERMAYER0.826317ANA
288HGILL0.827312TOR
289RJONES0.82839PHI
290KMALTBY0.83088DET
291LKUKKONEN0.83149CHI
292TLYDMAN0.833011BUF
293DTJARNQVIST0.833510EDM
294JMCCLEMENT0.83478STL
295MKNUBLE0.842812PHI
296DCLEARY0.856910DET
297JPITKANEN0.858216PHI
298SMORRISONN0.860412WSH
299CCLARK0.861912WSH
300DROY0.862411BUF
301KTKACHUK0.864413STL
302MZIDLICKY0.866315NSH
303NKRONVALL0.868812DET
304AWARD0.875913NYR
305MRUCINSKY0.876912STL
306BWITT0.877713NYI
307DWEIGHT0.881414STL
308PDUPUIS0.88949MIN
309MZIGOMANIS0.89029PHX
310CGRATTON0.89769FLA
311JSAKIC0.901515COL
312BHOLIK0.902312ATL
313MLOMBARDI0.908312CGY
314MMALHOTRA0.913410CBJ
315DZUBRUS0.914615WSH
316FPISANI0.918712EDM
317CBACKMAN0.919310STL
318KBIEKSA0.919617VAN
319SGONCHAR0.920019PIT
320CKELLY0.923511OTT
321DBRIERE0.924516BUF
322JSPACEK0.929115BUF
323EBREWER0.932517STL
324RKLESLA0.936915CBJ
325JSTOLL0.947913EDM
326BGERVAIS0.959211NYI
327PSHARP0.962012CHI
328APONIKAROVSKY0.976111TOR
329RNIEDERMAYER0.976112ANA
330MHEJDUK0.977713COL
331DARKHIPOV0.981011CHI
332DVYBORNY0.985516CBJ
333DARMSTRONG0.990012L.A
334MGREENE0.991812EDM
335RSMYTH0.993613EDM
336MRYDER1.002314MTL
337MKOIVU1.002415MIN
338PBOUCHER1.009116DAL
339SHILL1.014017NYI
340JDIPENTA1.017410ANA
341MSUNDIN1.024715TOR
342SFEDOROV1.025313CBJ
343SKOIVU1.025815MTL
344MSTAJAN1.027613TOR
345BWILLSIE1.031211L.A
346BMORRISON1.041015VAN
347MVAN RYN1.047516FLA
348RLANG1.048815DET
349JJAGR1.049820NYR
350CSCHUBERT1.052610OTT
351JHALPERN1.057413DAL
352DJANIK1.057913T.B
353AYASHIN1.065613NYI
354RMARTINEK1.067814NYI
355MAFINOGENOV1.072315BUF
356FMODIN1.078515CBJ
357TPOTI1.084319NYI
358ASEMIN1.094716WSH
359OVAANANEN1.124813COL
360KCARNEY1.133413MIN
361NWALLIN1.143612CAR
362LKRAJICEK1.151918VAN
363RBONK1.160213MTL
364KDRAPER1.161914DET
365MOHLUND1.166823VAN
366BBATTAGLIA1.200012TOR
367CCONROY1.214415L.A
368TRUUTU1.218515CHI
369SDONOVAN1.218613BOS
370MCOMMODORE1.236920CAR
371BMEZEI1.243713FLA
372SHNIDY1.257914ATL
373JCHIMERA1.314315CBJ
374TMARCHANT1.354214ANA
375RWARRENER1.371914CGY
376CBROWN1.404913S.J
377GWESLEY1.414615CAR
378DMOORE1.421814PIT
379APEREZHOGIN1.422914MTL
380KCALDER1.432916PHI
381MREASONER1.520415EDM
382JBULIS1.556818VAN
383SROBIDAS1.652525DAL
384MMALIK1.669719NYR
385JCULLIMORE1.827817CHI
386WPRIMEAU2.033521BOS

Division Graphs
What the graphs below show is the distribution of the above rates for different teams. The graphs are just estimated curves from a histogram of the individual rates. If there's more spread (like Vancouver) it means that the team has some excellent players and some terrible players. The other extreme is a tiny spread, such as New Jersey. You can also see the approximate averages for the teams from the graphs.








This is just a messy graph of all the teams together. I post it only so you can see the context of some of the divisional graphs above.
Team Stats
I figured since the graphs might be hard to read that I could post some of the numerical results.


TEAMCountMeanStDevMinimumMaximumRange
ANA140.62180.30780.28631.35421.0679
ATL110.58250.32920.16061.25791.0973
BOS120.7540.4610.3372.0341.697
BUF140.71520.19900.41391.07230.6584
CAR120.6770.4040.1351.4151.280
CBJ140.76840.27970.41741.31430.8969
CGY110.5980.3380.1831.3721.189
CHI120.7590.4470.2101.8281.618
COL130.63620.30370.09201.12481.0328
DAL130.6280.4250.0741.6531.578
DET150.72440.22320.39321.16190.7687
EDM150.72310.32960.21421.52041.3062
FLA150.66770.25540.37101.24370.8727
L.A130.64180.28170.33141.21440.8830
MIN150.54450.29870.13841.13340.9950
MTL140.73150.32800.16211.42291.2608
N.J140.36900.16520.06870.64390.5752
NSH130.44690.21160.14380.86630.7225
NYI120.75240.29780.30871.08430.7756
NYR120.75730.33390.46921.66971.2005
OTT160.56260.21990.26681.05260.7858
PHI90.6240.4030.1761.4331.257
PHX110.53230.19320.26800.89020.6222
PIT100.71270.31370.26571.42181.1561
S.J140.47830.30440.22391.40491.1810
STL140.73150.19400.33820.93250.5943
T.B130.52860.23490.20131.05790.8566
TOR120.6670.3790.1481.2001.053
VAN120.88870.29300.52861.55681.0282
WSH110.66760.27530.16231.09470.9324

February 3, 2007

Goaltender win statistic

Winning is the most important statistic for a goaltender in hockey. However, due to the fact that different teams win at different rates. Many teams could win with a terrible goaltender and the goaltender they use often gets a great win record (Cloutier, Theodore anyone). A great save percentage or GAA is worthless if it doesn't result in more wins. However you can calculate the likelihood of winning with a normal goaltender using a Pythagorean prediction: GF2/(GF2 + GA2), where GF = goaltender teams' scoring and GA = expected goals against. So if you score 3 and there are 2.8 expected goals against your goaltender: 32/(32 + 2.82) = 53%. If a goaltender looses a game when his team gets 7 goals for and there are the average 2.8 expected goals against: 72/(72 + 2.82) = 86%. Now if you sum up all those probabilities for any given goaltender then you get the number of expected wins. Then you just compare to the actual number of wins (I converted SOW/SOL to T and OTL to L). The difference between actual and expected gives you an idea how many extra wins a goalie is providing. However I wanted to scale out games played, so I divided by games played and multiplied by 60 (starting goaltender games per season), so that the W+ number represents the number of additional wins this goalie provides in the season where they play 60 games. A goalie like Luongo/Brodeur will play 70+ games so the numbers aren't perfect, but they're good enough.
W+ =60* (actual wins - expected wins)/GP
Here's the list [GP>10]:
NlastnamestatGPActualExpected
1HUET7.91331915
2GIGUERE7.72342622
3LUONGO6.17482824
4MASON6.08312017
5BRODEUR4.63503127
6EMERY4.28352119
7TURCO3.50442421
8HASEK3.44382725
9LEGACE3.33351615
10TOSKALA3.17292120
11NABOKOV3.17231211
12BACKSTROM3.081466
13NORRENA2.97271413
14VOKOUN2.56221414
15LEHTONEN2.50452220
16FLEURY2.28412322
17TELLQVIST1.761688
18KIPRUSOFF1.57462625
19BELFOUR1.54281414
20AEBISCHER1.301999
21WARD1.21402322
22RAYCROFT1.15432423
23FERNANDEZ0.77391918
24MILLER0.72372121
25KHABIBULIN0.54361818
26JOSEPH0.50301212
27DIPIETRO0.43391919
28JOHNSON0.281455
29BIRON0.20161111
30KOLZIG0.10381818
31THOMAS0.08381818
32LUNDQVIST-0.22391819
33DUNHAM-0.251244
34HOLMQVIST-0.75271515
35GRAHAME-0.791455
36ESCHE-1.011456
37BUDAJ-1.50301516
38ROLOSON-1.61442022
39TOIVONEN-1.901133
40SANFORD-3.681134
41LECLAIRE-4.532068
42GERBER-5.1218810
43BRYZGALOV-6.121467
44THEODORE-6.2821811
45GARON-6.3318810
46AULD-6.4425811
47Boucher-6.871424
48WEEKES-7.531246
49CLOUTIER-7.912269
50NIITTYMAKI-8.1737813
51DENIS-8.82261014


It should be noted that luck plays a bigger part in these statistics as there aren't many events (<50), these results could be interpreted as random, however the list is a good representation of how man goaltenders on this list have played. I'll try going back a few season later on to see what happens when I include more data.

February 2, 2007

Scorers: West vs. East

The differences in the west and east are interesting to say the least. Most would agree the western conference is better than the eastern conference. However, scoring is higher out east (by about 10%) and the west is about 5% better than the East. So in order to put the two conferences on an even foothold I made every point in the west worth 1.15 eastern points. Now I personally have a problem with this choice, but I figure it's adequate enough. Then I plotted the results below in a histogram (it's hard to two histograms on the same plot well), but the curve represents the data quite well. The western curve is significantly different from the eastern curve. You can see that the west has quite a few more players in the 0.4-1.2 category, whereas the east dominates the 0-0.3. In other words the East is not as good as the west because it has more marginal players. Basically the west has more depth: better 2nd powerplay unit, better 5th and 6th defenseman etc.

I looked into goaltending as a possibility, but both divisions have the same save percentage.

Statistically out of the playoffs

There's often a lot of talk about the point where one is "mathematically out of the playoffs". Websites typically put an 'e-' in front of the team for whom it is impossible to make the playoffs. Often before you are officially eliminated the situation for you to make the playoffs would have to be really bizarre. That is to say in order for Philadelphia to make the playoffs at this point they'd need to win a lot of games and all the top teams would need to start losing. Sometimes the situation is so unlikely it's better just conclude it's impossible statistically speaking.

For example we currently have about 30 games left. A 50% team has a 43% chance of playing above 50% and 43% chance of playing worse (leaving 14% for 15 wins out of 30 games). Of course, what I care about here is that there's a 5% chance that a 50% team wins 20 or more games. In other words if a team needs to win 20/30 games to make the playoffs then they have a 5% chance of making the playoffs (if they're average). Of course most bad teams (those who don't make playoffs) are below 50%, but I'm assuming a team might play a little better to make the playoffs. This is done following the simple binomial distribution. As you get closer to the last game of the season there is a higher likelihood that you could win 100% the remaining games: (1/2)games left, and a similar relationship exists for winning 90% or 80% of remaining games.

Of course winning percentage doesn't make much sense in the new NHL. I use a system that assumes each team will get 8 additional points during the course of the season (10% of games) and so winning percentage equals:
w% = (W+OTL/2)/GP-0.05

Due to the fact that the binomial distribution is discrete you can't solve for an exact value so I did a regression on the last 30 games to show the sort of functional relationship between games remaining and statistically impossible winning percentage.
cut-off = 0.763 - 0.452 *ln(ln(ln(games left))) [or = 1 if games left < 7]

Although it looks complicated, the nested 'ln' functions are necessary to get the appropriate curvature.

Using this equation and a guess for the number of points to make playoffs (~93 points) you can estimate the required winning percentage
Required% = (93-2*W-OTL)/[2*(82-Games Played)]-0.05.

And if required% > cut-off then you have less than a 5% chance of making the playoffs.

Of course the opposite is true if required% < (1-cut-off) then the team is statistically making the playoffs.

Of course if the team is better than 50% for whatever reason (star player just got back from long term injury).

Most of the results are obvious, but in the Blue Jackets, Blackhawks and Kings are out and in the East just Philadelphia. Ducks, Predators and Red Wings are making the playoffs in the West and it appears that Buffalo has secured a spot out East. These statistics are presented on my website.

January 19, 2007

Attendance Demand.

Attendance is about as complicated as they come. I’m not sure I can tackle this with the limited data available and only partial information of the market forces. Attendance primarily depends on the demand for: “going to hockey games”, price of tickets, and population. I should quickly mention there was a change in how attendance was reported in 2000-2001 as such I had to add a $10 increase to the stated value and increase attendance by 200. [Many of the factors involved are complicated and I lack the information or time to look at them all in detail]. Normalizing ticket prices is trivial as there are nice simple CPI calculators (~2.5%/year) that do a great job and it appears that before the lockout the optimal average was about $55. In order to look at demand I had to also normalize attendance. Now there is no CPI for attendance, looking at the years where prices were stable I was able to estimate attendance growth to approximately 2.5% per year. Now the American Population grows at around 1%, so it’s somewhere in that range. I found a 2% growth rate for New York, which probably accurately measures most cities and so I used 2% natural growth rate for attendance, changing this number slightly has large effects on the results. I’m not sure how important ticket sales are in terms of the hockey business, but 16000*$55*41*30 = $1.1B or half of league revenue. If you use all the above data you get a graph that looks like:

Now the regression on price for the pre-lockout years looks like:

[ Attendance = 22574 – 142 * Price ]

Or each dollar increase/decrease in prices costs the organization about 142 people. If you maximize that Attendance*Price you get $80, that certainly wouldn’t be popular and would only increase ticket revenue by about $100M (10%). Or a price increase of 50% would increase revenue by 10%; of course less revenue would be received from consumables and merchandise as well. So I can’t really say whether it would be beneficial without understand all aspects of their revenue. That being said raising ticket prices by a dollar would increase ticket revenue by about $7,000*1230 = $9M.

Some may note that it appears that price of tickets is increasing every year; this is to be expected as population increases:

[ Optimal price: 22574*(1+population growth rate)year/284 = Price ]

In other words prices should grow as fast as population. If not, there’s something else going on.


However the real question that everyone probably cares about is: what was the cost of the lockout in terms of attendance? So I did a quick regression on Price, and whether or not the information came after the lockout:

[ Attendance = 22622 – 143*Price - 1486 Lockout ]

Basically the lockout cost the NHL about 1500 people per game; of course it doesn’t look that way as attendance averages have increased. The past two years of attendance increases have been the result of lower ticket prices and population increases. This costs the NHL about $100M per year until it regains that 1500 loss (if never then you can discount [at 2%] $100M to infinity for a net cost of $5B). The GMs probably believe that the benefits of the new CBA exceeded the costs. Such as the immediate $400M dollar saving in salaries (guess) and possible future saving caused by the cap.

In conclusion I did all this to show that while the NHL is very proud of its attendance figures it’s actually nothing to be proud of. They’ve lost a significant amount of fans and this can be seen by the lower ticket prices. I’m not sure if the future is predicting that the NHL recovers these lost fans (attendance increases faster than population until it reaches it’s old trajectory), however there aren’t really any good signs that is happening at this point. Maybe the 2006-2007 figures will improve as we get closer to the playoffs. But don't panic, Betman isn't even as Colorado see s 12/23 home games not sell out.

January 17, 2007

Diving Update.

I’ve said a bit about diving in the past. And as people posted they wanted to see how it played out through the season. In the first 500 games or so this season the NHL wanted to make a statement that they were cracking down on diving. Interestingly those statements have faded since November. The media appears to have gone silent and interestingly enough it appears there no more upper management pressure on referees to call these penalties. Avery got his third diving call (next requires a suspension) costing him 0.2% of his current income (I guess it’s the cost of being in his business), however there appears to be no news coverage on the fine he should’ve received. I’m curious if the NHL will give Avery the fourth to make a point or if they’re just bluffing about the suspension.

The point of this post however is just to show the interesting trend in diving calls over the season:

Games:

2005-2006

2006-2007

0-99

11

14

100-199

10

14

200-299

5

12

300-399

4

10

400-499

9

13

500-599

8

5

600-699

8

6

It’s interesting that the 2005-2006 had the same sort of diving calls occurring in games 200-399 as 2006-2007 is having in games 500-699. Now my database is missing 6 games from the 600-699 set, however 4 of those played today had no diving calls and it’s unlikely that the two games left played tomorrow will have a diving call.

In my opinion, I think there is probably one significant dive per game and probably twice that number of additional minor dives however the NHL seems to believe there is around one dive every ten games and even less when they’re not marketing the diving rules.

January 15, 2007

Plus Minus Graphs II

David Johnson provided a neat suggestion that the plus minus graphs should include the team along with it. 1 problem with doing this is that the X axis is time played and the Y axis is plus minus. Any given team will have more even strength time than any player so graphing the numbers together would just make the individual graph portion a small part at the beginning with a very long portion for the team data. So instead I scaled the team data down by the same percentage the player plays on a per game basis. So that the slopes are the same and the length of both curves are equal and each segment represents a game played.

Instead of graphing the team data as it is, I decided to remove the ice time and plus minus data of the given player so that the two are relatively independent of each other. This closely mimics that of Behind the Net On-Ice/Off-Ice statistics. However it only looks at the games they were involved in (where as behind the net takes the entire season average).

So to get me started I'll use Jovanovski as an example. A top defenseman on a terrible team, as you can see below, Jovanovski has done quite well in his circumstances. Even though Jovanovski has played on a relatively bad team he's managed reasonable numbers.
  • Individual (blue) Slope (red): 0.54 ±/HR
  • Team (grey-red) Slope (light pink): -0.76 ±/HR
  • Difference: 1.3 ±/HR
I found this one to be possibly the most interesting, Thomas Vanek. The rest of the team has significantly upward sloping team curves, but Vanek has managed to be the one player who makes all the other players look average. A difference of 2.09 isn't the best in the NHL, since he's on a good team, but the score is quite good.

  • Individual (blue) Slope (red): 2.47 ±/HR
  • Team (grey-red) Slope (light pink): 0.38 ±/HR
  • Difference: 2.09 ±/HR
As far as I'm concerned this is the most drastic difference in the NHL and this is Jagr. A difference of 3.43 is quite remarkable, although you can see Jagr hasn't been doing as well in recent games as he has in the past, but the team is getting better.
  • Individual (blue) Slope (red): 1.63 ±/HR
  • Team (grey-red) Slope (light pink): -1.81 ±/HR
  • Difference: 3.43 ±/HR
A number of things to remember is that: The difference scores are not really measures of skill, they probably remove some effects and are therefor better measures of skill that other alternatives. For example, Shanahan in New York, suffers from the fact that when he's not on the ice Jagr is, so he is certainly worse than Jagr, but that doesn't make him a bad player.

I'm not sure who's responsible for making Phoenix so bad, but Morris and Scatchard certainly aren't the best two players in the NHL, but on a bad team both of these players are making the team look average.
Morris: ($3.9M)

Scatchard: ($2.1M)
And if anyone is wondering who is responsible for Philadelphia's -1.71 ±/HR you need not look any further than Calder ($3M):


The rest of these graphs can be found on my website by clicking on a players name.

January 14, 2007

Plus Minus Graphs

Hockey often looks at highly variable statistics in order to determine averages that aren’t very accurate. What we care about is the true figure, but it often masked by a week of great play or a bad week. A great start to the season could give an average player a great plus minus for the entire season, whether it’s a measure of his true skill or not it will appear in the final results. A way of fixing this is to look at all the data between the start of the season and the current time and see what the trend is doing rather than just looking at the final result. For this example I’m going to use plus minus statistics. This will remove some of the luck in the results and make the results more real. Take for example Heatley with a 4.1 +/hr and 2.2 -/hr, he is measured as a ±1.9/hr (+23 in 12.1hours), however if you do a regression on his game by game data you’ll find that it looks like:



The spike at end allowing him to go from +12 to +23 in just 4 games, which appears to be an anomaly. The regression spits out a slope of +1.18/hr, which seems a little more reasonable, but significantly different from the 1.9 +/hr, which is the official average. You might also notice the slope doesn’t start at the origin (he is +2 before the season starts), this is an attempt to scale out luck at the beginning and so the regression doesn’t chase the results at the end of the regression. The goal is to find the best slope to fit the data and if one fixes the starting point you can only swivel around that point and so the regression will chase the final value because that is the one it can change the most as a small change is slope has the most effect on the values furthest from the origin.

The benefit of such a method is in terms of error. In general the standard deviation for the plus minus statistic is: sqrt(plusses + minuses), so Heatley works out to about ±8 of course it’s not quite that simple because plusses aren’t purely independent of minuses, although the best error it could be is sqrt(plus-minus), for Heatley this is sqrt(23) or 4.8. Using the regression method we get a standard error for the fit of 0.7, which is much better than the simple average. You can see the same effect with Crosby who is +4.2 and -2.5 (difference = 1.7), the regression says he’s playing at +2.3/hr or 35% than his simple average suggests due to the fact he’s on a mini even strength slump.



It’s a rather simple adjustment to how to look at the data, and it can produce some striking results. Most of the time this should produce the same results as a simple average due to the fact the most likely place for a variable to be at is close to the true mean then anywhere else, but in cases where there is a divergent short term trend that is significantly effect the final results this should produce better results.

The rest of the NHL results can be found on my website.